As a coastal destination surrounded by water, it’s no surprise that the seafood in Anna Maria Island is always fresh and full of flavor, with local favorites like grouper and stone crab leading the way. Beyond seafood, the island’s dining scene offers something for everyone, from laid-back beach bistros and casual burger spots to charming cafés and romantic waterfront restaurants. Whether you’re craving barbecue by the sand or classic Italian paired with a glass of wine and a glowing sunset over the bay, you’ll find it all here. For more than just great dining, BeachGuide has a complete guide to everything visitors might be looking for while staying on the island, including beaches, attractions, and local favorites, plus a wide selection of vacation rentals in Anna Maria Island to make your stay unforgettable.